Muslim: Coptic Christian attack a ‘failure to accept the other’

Dr. Tawfik Hamid is a moderate Muslim who was a radical Islamist jihadi. A serious insider into the mind of a Muslim fundamentalist, he now writes insightful articles into the nature of Islam. He has asked me to post this article. Thank you, Dr. Hamid, for courageously telling the truth!

(Emphasis in bold is mine – please pay close attention to what he says there! Please support Tawfik by signing up for his newsletter at his site link below.)

The Underlying Cause of the Attack on Coptic Christians: ‘Failure to accept the other’.

By Tawfik Hamid
http://www.tawfikhamid.com/

A powerful bomb, possibly from a suicide attacker, exploded in front of a Coptic Christian church on January 1 as a crowd of worshippers emerged from a New Year Mass early Saturday, killing at least 21 people and wounding more than 90 in an attack that raised suspicions of an al-Qaida role.

This barbaric attack raised many concerns and points for discussion.

The reactions by some commentators and politicians to say that the attack was on both Muslims and Christians, as televised on several Arab TV stations, can be perceived by some as a desire to show unity between Muslims and Christian; however, on the contrary, it can be seen by others as a thinly veiled attempt to underestimate and dilute the threat posed by radical Islamists to the Coptic Christian minority in Egypt. The selection of this time of the year to conduct the attack clearly demonstrates the desire of the attackers to kill as many Christians as possible in the Church – and not the mosque, since Muslims do not have formal prayer at this late time of the night. Furthermore, attempts to avoid mentioning that Christians were targeted in this attack added fuel to the fire and can partially explain the furious reaction of some Coptic Christians after the attack. However, in the end analysis, it is fair to say that the attackers – while targeting Christians – had a bigger mission in mind which is to ignite a civil war and destabilize the secular regime in Egypt to allow radical Islamists to rule the country. The terrorists simply tried to “get more than one bird with the same stone”.

The reflexive response of some commentators and politicians to point a finger at unspecified foreign powers claiming that they are behind the attacks without having any concrete evidence to prove this point is counterproductive and unscientific. It is wiser to wait for the police and intelligence reports before jumping to such conclusions. In fact, some well-known Arabic news media such as Almesryoon.com did not hesitate without any proof to point the finger of blame at Coptic groups that are supported by the Israeli Mossed as being behind this attack.  Blaming others without concrete evidence instead of admitting that there is a problem that must be fixed limits the ability to solve this problem. Problems can be solved only if we are objective and honest.  This lack of honest objectivity is the signature response today across the broader Islamic world.

Looking at the attack of January 1 in the context of other recent terror acts against Christian minorities in Iraq and the former attacks on Coptic Christians in Egypt such as at the Cathedral of Nagaa Hamadi Jan 8 2010, (Nagaa Hamadi is a city that is located 700 kilometers south of Cairo) leaves little doubt that Christian minorities are being targeted by Islamist terrorists. The shooting of crosses by Al-Qaeda members in their training camps in Afghanistan that were videotaped and released few years ago further illustrates the purposeful targeting of Christians. However, it would be naïve to presume that the Al-Qudea threat is only limited to Christians. In fact, the group has attacked and indiscriminately killed thousands of Muslims including Shi’ia in Iraq, Sufis in Pakistan, and Sunnis in Algeria. Radical Islamic groups also killed hundreds of innocent Jews in Israel and slaughtered many Buddhists in Thailand. Attacking followers of different faiths, views, or believes by Islamic Radicals illustrates that the problem of the Christian minorities in the Middle East is part of a global threat that we must face and confront. Killing people from different faiths and beliefs by the hands of radical Islamists elucidates the true and underlying cause of the problem of radical Islam which is: failure to accept the ‘other’. Inability of radical Islamists to tolerate the ‘other’ has undeniable roots and a strong basis in the current mainstream teachings in the Muslim world that undervalue the life of others if they are different. Leading Islamic scholars do not necessarily teach young Muslims to conduct suicide bombings; however, they teach them intolerance and an under-appreciation of the lives of those who are different from them. Such teachings are the initial step and the first building blocks in the creation of the mind of a suicide bomber.

These teachings specifically include the following:

1-    The “Redda Law” that justify killing Muslims if they rejected Islam

2-    The unchallenged Islamic jurisprudence rule that justifies killing non-Muslims if they refused to convert to Islam and reject paying a humiliating tax for Muslims (Jizzia),

3-    The rule that the compensation for the life of Christians or Jews is only half of that for a Muslim if they were killed by a Muslim.

In other words, if the Islamic scholars rejected these teachings and provided an alternative that respects the ‘other’ and tolerates diversity, it will be much more difficult for the terrorists to promote their suicidal and homicidal ideology.

It is important and fair to mention that the current secular laws in Egypt do not follow such teachings; however, the mainstream religious educational system continues to promote such values without challenging them or providing an alternative.

Finally, the very negative side of the calamity of January 1 must not make us ignore the other side of the coin. The disaster can be the spark that might start the needed change. The reaction of the Egyptians, including the unprecedented media coverage of the incident, the fast response of President Mubarak to address the nation, addressing the role of ideology and education in creating the problem by some leading government officials in Egypt such as Dr. Mustafa al-Fiqi, (the Chairman of the Committees of the Arab Relations, Foreign Relations, and National Security in the Egyptian Parliament), and the demonstrations of both Muslims and Christians together who raised the cross and the Quran to show solidarity with one another gives some hope that a change in the Islamic world may be starting. The question still remains: Is this momentum for a change going to continue?

6 Comments

Add a Comment
  1. I’ve been in Egypt a few years ago and, there were quite a few churches there… and it made me afraid such a thing may happen… and it did, unfortunately, we can expect something similar to happen in Tunisia or/and Turkey, both have a strong Christian minority and both are reasonably secularised.

    Radical Muslims may not have any support from other Muslims, but only one (in a million) is enough to make a very “normal” place very “unnormal”

  2. Dear Brethren in the Lord,

    Greetings to you in the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ the Saviour of the whole World.

    And by the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ I am the Founder of Evangelical Prayer testimony Fellowship Ministry located here in Lahore City, Islamic Republic of Pakistan
    the grace of God, I am married and blessed with two Children. This Ministry was founded primarily to reach the lost souls because the harvest is truly plenteous but the laborers are few.

    We reach out the saving message of our Lord Jesus Christ to the Souls in the Market, remote Villages and the Prison as well and I am giving God all the glory because Souls are been transformed for eternity. We also have Orphanage home as well and Please Join us in Praying for these Children. Souls are repenting from their ways of Life and they are now serving our Lord Jesus Christ and wining Souls for His Kingdom as well.

    There is great need for Bibles, Food, Accommodation for our Precious Converts over here in my Country and I am praying and believing God that He is going to use you to send us these Bibles for these Souls so that they can have a copy of the Bible
    their own Bible to Study daily. My beloved Brethren, I am asking you to pray also for the above need
    help us with 11 Giant Print Bibles for our Precious Converts who are in need of the Word of God the ” HOLY BIBLE “.

    And I hope to hear from you on how you will help us with these Bibles and pray for special needs
    because these Converts cannot buy one for themselves and the reason I am requesting for Large Print Bibles for these Converts is because they are aged and cannot read small Character Bibles and may the Lord Almighty reward you abundantly as you help these Souls with the needed Bibles soon.

    Thanks and I pray that the Peace of God be with you and your family. I do hope to hear from you soon and I would love to walk with you in the area of Reaching out to the Lost Souls and I do pray that God will provide the needed resources for you so that you can come and visit us. Kindly visit us also our website http://www.eptministry.org

    Yours in Christ,

    Evangelist Javed Sindhu

    Evangelical Prayer testimony Fellowship Ministry ®

    1. Ask GOD to give you these items ?????

  3. Looks like …
    Scammer/spammer emails I get every day from Nigerian con men.

  4. And now …
    We have the rot of “Arab Spring” in Egypt, the Copts are all but slaughtered and extinct and Egypt is about to get hammered into non-existence by Israel.

  5. More like Arab Winter
    I see the entire Arab world going backwards. It’s a shame, because in the case of Egypt, they went from a totalitarian, dictatorial regime to the Muslim Brotherhood… People like that and the Taliban don’t really care if their fellow Muslims continue to suffer, and in some cases want them to so they can blame the rest of the world for their problems… I think these governments should be viewed more often as if the Nazi’s are coming to power. The Taliban reminds me of Pol Pot and his ‘revolution’. They insist that the West is to blame, and if a Muslim dies or is killed by the West they stir up their fervor to incite riots, but how come their are no demonstrations from them or anywhere in the Muslim world when thousands of Muslims are killed by other Muslims (like Iraq)? Also when terrorist organizations such as Al Qaeda, if they support the Palestinian cause and Hamas so much why aren’t they there helping them. These people are very much like their religion, in constant contradiction with what they say and do. As for Hamas, and every other Muslim/ sharia based governments, if Israel were truly gone, they would still fight against one another for who will be the first among equals (yeah like communism)!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

*

© 2015 Freethought Nation, Acharya S, D.M. Murdock & Stellar House Publishing
Skysa App Bar